Conversion Practices Prohibition Bill 2026 – Second Reading Speech

Home » Parliament » Conversion Practices Prohibition Bill 2026 – Second Reading Speech
Cassy O'Connor MLC
November 17, 2026

Ms O’CONNOR – Mr President, I move –

That the bill be now read a second time.

The Conversion Practices Prohibition Bill of 2026 recognises the fundamental human right of people to live as who they are, free from the harm caused by those who don’t or won’t accept the reality of human diversity and matters of sexual orientation and gender identity – those who believe there’s something wrong with them, who seek to change them, to suppress or eradicate their fundamental nature.

It is our right as human beings to be free from discrimination, vilification, harassment and harm on the basis of a wide range of attributes, including our sexual orientation and gender identity. Tasmanian law reflects that through the Anti-Discrimination Act 1998. The bill we debate today seeks to strengthen that protection from the harm caused by, at best, a misunderstanding of human diversity – the very biological, emotional and psychological facts of it – and at worst, ignorance, prejudice and a faith in junk science.

Australia has recognised that love is love. Whether a consenting adult who is straight, lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, born with a range of sex characteristics, asexual or agendered. We have legalised marriage equality, fought as it was every step of the way by most of the churches and the reactionary right. Love won; the sky hasn’t fallen in. There is equality before the law for LGBTIQA+ people, and Australia is a better place for it.

In the same way, should Tasmania follow the lead now set by other jurisdictions and prohibit conversion practices, our island will be a kinder, safer place for the significant proportion of our population who identify as LGBTIQA+. The Conversion Practices Prohibition Bill of 2026 prohibits practices and conduct aimed at changing, suppressing or eradicating the sexual orientation or gender identity of a person. The bill provides a tiered approach with an education, prevention and response scheme (EPRS) for lower-level conduct and a new criminal offences for serious conduct.

The scheme allows for a person to make a report about a conversion practice that’s happened and establish a voluntary process facilitated by the Conversion Commissioner, where an agreement can be reached, the report can be referred to the tribunal for assessment. The scheme also provides for the commissioner to proactively investigate serious or systemic conversion practices and to publish findings as well as accept an undertaking or issue compliance notices to prevent conversion practices.

For serious conduct, the bill establishes criminal offences for engaging in conversion practices that cause injury and for taking a person outside Tasmania for conversion practices.

Conversion practices that aim to change, suppress or eradicate the sexual orientation or gender identity of another person often present as pseudoscientific or pseudo medical practices. These practices are based on the twin beliefs that change of a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity is possible and desirable or even necessary.

Both conversion practices and the beliefs behind them are firmly rejected by medical and scientific evidence and the experience of survivors. The Australian Psychological Society position statement on conversion practices reads:

Approaches to mental health practice, variously referred to as ‘reparative’, ‘conversion’ or ‘ex-gay’ therapy are based on the assumption that being lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender or queer is indicative of a psychological dysfunction and that this can be ‘cured’. No professional health organisation in Australia supports these approaches for the following reasons:

  1. There is no clinical evidence demonstrating that approaches that claim to change or suppress a person’s sexual orientation or gender are effective.
  2. There is, however, a considerable body of evidence documenting the negative effects of stigma associated with being a member of the LGBTQ plus communities, including higher rates of depression.
  3. There is also clinical evidence that change or suppression practices are harmful and can compound the challenges already faced by LGBTQ+ communities.

The Tasmanian Law Reform’s 2022 report on conversion practices found the harms caused by them include isolation from and loss of trust in religious leaders or medical professionals, low self-esteem, self-hatred, anxiety, depression, trauma, substance abuse, a reluctance to seek medical treatment, suicidal ideation, suicide attempts and suicides. It also found that –

These harms often last for many years and trauma can persist for life for survivors.

The TLRI found that conversion practices still happen in Tasmania. Forty-six submissions to the institute reported people being offered or undergoing conversion practices. Other submissions implied or directly stated that they conduct conversion practices in Tasmania. Prevalent studies have estimated between 5 and 14 per cent of Australian LGBTIQA+ people have been exposed to conversion practices.

The TLRI report contained testimonials from people who had undergone conversion practices. They showed these harmful practices are not confined to the past and highlight the risks of allowing even so-called ‘consensual’ conversion practices. This account is from a then-25-year-old trans person –

My faith is a huge part of who I am. It’s the foundation of me. Back when I was at

\- a school that has been redacted –

I wanted to join a social group for my faith, and since service to others in the community is a core value of my faith, I wanted to be an active member of that group. For a while it was great – I was part of the group’s music crew and volunteered at events and it seemed to be a really warm, loving community dynamic.

And then they found out I was trans.

Suddenly, I got booted out of the music crew and got banned from volunteering. I was told by the group’s leadership that I could still be a member, but only if I ‘abstained’ from being who I am and didn’t ever mention it again. They prayed for me to be ‘healed’.

The sense of whiplash was incredible. Being cut off from my faith community so suddenly, it was like I couldn’t breathe. They said I could rejoin the music crew on the condition that I denounced my identity publicly and went to regular ‘healing’ prayer sessions. For a while I tried to continue attending the group’s events, pretending I was a good little cis-het girl just to be there, but I couldn’t keep it up. Everyone had suddenly become so cold and knowing that my acceptance in that community was contingent on me lying about who I am – that damage was done. I couldn’t be at home there anymore, and I couldn’t trust any of those people. It hurt so bad, like my family had died but was somehow still standing around making small talk with each other.

It totally destroyed my self-worth, I hated myself. I started drinking myself into oblivion every night, sleeping with strangers compulsively and putting myself in unsafe situations. I thought I deserved to suffer and I was going to hell anyway so I might as well get there a bit quicker.

I guess I’m one of the lucky ones in that it didn’t end up actually stopping me transitioning, and I made it to a better place eventually. But I lost so much.

Honestly, I still don’t trust any faith groups. I haven’t been able to be part of any since. I don’t know how to find a church community where I’ll be able to feel safe, and not like they might suddenly turn on me. My faith is still the core of my identity, but trying to find other people to share that with is too much for me most of the time.

The next account is from a 28-year-old trans person.

When I – utterly terrified – finally told my pastor I was trans and asked him if there was any hope for me, his tone didn’t really change. He’d always been worried for me, and he stayed as gentle and kind as he’d always been. But gently, kindly, he told me that queerness was a kind of spiritual brokenness and I needed to be healed and it was part of his calling to help me find my way back to ‘what God intended’ for me.

To have the main authority and parental figure in my life tell me that who I was was fundamentally wrong and corrupted by the Devil? Saying out loud all the things my anxiety and depression had been saying inside my head? I can’t explain what that felt like. Multiple times a week we’d have one-on-one ‘Bible studies’ that were all about convincing me to change my sinful heart and let God heal me. The other emotional and material help my pastor had been giving me all stopped.

My girlfriend got taken in for compulsory ‘faith counselling’, too. They told her she had to break up with me, that she wasn’t the right person to guide me back to righteousness, and that if she wanted to stay at that church, she wasn’t allowed to talk to me or sit with me during services anymore. She needed the church community, so she stopped talking to me. I don’t blame her.

A month into my ‘rehabilitation’ I tried to kill myself. I left the church after that. I actually tried to kill myself a few times over the next few years. I guess I was pretty bad at it.

I’d like to say I’m all better these days, but I’m not. I’m still totally fucked up. I can’t hold down a relationship. My faith is a source of constant pain. I’m scared of Christians, but I’m a Christian still so I can’t practice my own faith. I feel safest around other queer people who hate Christianity because of how it’s treated them, but then I end up feeling like they hate that part of me and I have to keep that secret. I can’t be my whole self anywhere. Deep down, I think I still believe I deserve to suffer. I don’t know if things will ever get better for me, but any laws that could stop that happening to someone else are a good thing, as far as I’m concerned. [TBC]

What these and many similar stories show us are the actual experience of people subject to conversion practices. Some have advocated for this bill to allow consensual conversion practices to occur. These stories highlight the reality of what can actually occur in sessions that are airbrushed over with the relatively benign language of ‘consensual pastoral care’ and ‘client-identified goals.’

In psychology and health practices, the requirement for agreeing to an intervention is not consent; informed consent is what it is. Informed consent must be free from coercion, manipulation or undue influence and must involve clear communication for the reasons and the risks of a treatment or practice. All major health and psychology representative bodies in Australia and worldwide have consistently denounced conversion practices, describing them as harmful and not effective in their stated purpose. These include the Australian Medical Association, Australian Psychology Association, the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists, the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners and the Royal Australasian College of Physicians.

It’s not possible for conversion practices to practically occur with informed consent because the underlying principles require agreeing that a person can and should change their sexual orientation or gender identity. These are both soundly discredited claims. They’re also contrary to professional standards for relevant health professionals. It is not plausible that a person would willingly and freely agree to undergo a conversion practice if they understood it would fail to meet its stated purpose and it was likely to cause significant harm. The reality is that the coercion people often experience is systemic, with multiple people or institutions convincing people that their self is broken and unless they participate in conversion practices they won’t fit in or be accepted. In these situations, conversion practices don’t need to coerce people; surrounding systems and institutions are set up to do it for them.

There are a number of amendments that were passed in the Assembly. Ms Johnston, Mr George, Mr O’Byrne, Mr Jaensch and the Premier engaged with us on amendments that added clarity and addressed areas of community concern. On behalf of the Greens, I warmly thank them for their engagement, just as I thank my honourable colleagues in here who, over the past couple of weeks, have engaged very constructively and openly on this bill. I’m really thankful for the collaborative way that it’s been handled across both Houses. Dr Woodruff also moved amendments based on feedback from the honourable member Ms Palmer that added value to the bill, and I thank the minister for her sincere and positive engagement on the bill. That was done, of course, in the interest of children and young people and the guardians in their lives.

Clause 3 was amended by inserting a new subparagraph (v) into paragraph (b). This subparagraph clarifies that a serious breach of the positive duty is also grounds for an investigation, as per clause 39(a)(i). This better aligns the objects with the EPRS scheme and doesn’t make functional changes.

A definition of ‘guardian’ was inserted into clause 4 and the term ‘parent’ in clause 5(4)(f) was replaced with ‘guardian’. This was one of the matters raised by Ms Palmer who in particular wanted to ensure foster carers are captured. To place on the Hansard in this place, I can advise that, in the Children, Young Persons and Their Families Act 1997,

guardian means –

\(a\) a parent of a child; and

\(b\) a person (other than the Secretary) who is the legal guardian of a child; and

\(c\) a person (other than the Secretary) –

\(d\) any other person (other than the Secretary) who generally acts in the place of a parent and has done so for a significant length of time.

While legal custody is not defined, it originally mirrored the term ‘legal custody’ used in the Commonwealth Family Law Act 1975, which has subsequently changed its terminology. However, the historic definition of legal custody in that act was:

The right to have the daily care and control of the child, and the right and responsibility to make decisions concerning the daily care and control of the child.

Which we understand, covers foster care.

This clause was also expanded to include guidance, support or advice, in respect of sexual activity or religion, in addition to discussion. This is consistent with the original intent of this paragraph, includes a more inclusive term than ‘parent,’ and adds clarity for those concerned that ‘discussion’ was too narrow.

Other amendments were made to the avoidance of doubt provisions in clause 5(4). Paragraph (b) was amended to include a sermon, religious education and pastoral care as well as prayer, in respect of an expression of a belief or principle. Prayer was originally listed as a non-exhaustive example, so these inclusions give additional clarity for the avoidance of doubt provisions, these are, and they remain, consistent with the original intent of this paragraph. These two amendments we worked through with Mr O’Byrne and the Premier.

Clause 5(4)(g) was also inserted to cover age-appropriate relationships and sexuality education. This is consistent with the kind of conduct that the bill does not capture and fits comfortably with the avoidance of doubt provisions. This was another amendment made based on discussions with the minister, Ms Palmer.

Avoidance of doubt provisions are important to appropriately balance, to ensure the intended security and comfort are provided, while avoiding the risk of undermining the bill. This has been a very careful process, and I again thank the members involved in these amendments for working through them constructively with us.

There are also a number of amendments to the principles in clause 8. Paragraph (b) was amended to change the language of ‘should be welcomed, valued and respected’ to ‘have the right to be treated in a way that makes them feel welcomed, valued and respected.’ Paragraph (c) now reflects that language of both the former paragraph (c) and (d), and paragraph (e) has been inserted, which provides that ‘responses under this Act should, where appropriate, prioritise education and prevention.’ All of these amendments are consistent with the purpose of the bill and the principles section. These amendments were moved by Mr George, the member for Franklin, who worked closely with us to address his concerns, while also balancing the intent of the principles and the strong views of the community and stakeholders on what these needed to cover.

The former clause 19 established employer liability for conversion practices offences. This was removed in the House of Assembly. I note that the bill is not primarily a punitive model, and vicarious liability remains in the bill in respect of the Education and Prevention Scheme. The minister, Mr Jaensch had a particular interest in removing vicarious liability and retrospectivity from the bill. I’m advised that there were constructive conversations about this during debate in the House and, as I understand it, the supportive members were all, after discussion, comfortable with the removal of vicarious liability for the criminal provisions of the bill, but the retaining of vicarious liability for the Education Prevention and Response Scheme.

There are a range of amendments aimed at providing greater clarity and clearer detail regarding the relationship between a facilitation agreement and the tribunal process. The previous language of ‘finally resolve,’ in respect of a facilitation agreement led to some confusion. There was some concern that determining what constitutes a ‘final resolution’ may be difficult in some circumstances. The amendments, instead of providing the circumstances in which a matter can be referred to the tribunal, allow for a referral to occur, so long as a facilitation isn’t active, and instead clarify that a tribunal can’t make orders contrary to a facilitation agreement unless it’s in the interests of justice to do so. This framework makes it clearer what can happen in circumstances where an agreement has been reached that may not fully resolve all matters. Clause 39B in respect of when an investigation may occur was amended from conduct that amounts to a possible contravention of this act to a possible material contravention of this act. It was not the intention of the bill that an investigation would occur if a breach was not a material breach, and as such this amendment does not alter the intent of the bill.

I very much thank the Premier for working through this amendment with us to ensure explicit clarity for the appropriate threshold. Clause 52A was amended to reflect the fact that an investigation may relate to a positive duty contravention and clarifies that a compliance notice must also state grounds in this respect if relevant. Clause 52A was amended to reflect the fact that an investigation may relate to a positive duty contravention and clarifies that a compliance notice must also state grounds in this respect, if relevant.

Clause 53, vicarious liability, was also amended in response to matters raised by minister Palmer. A new subsection 4 has been inserted to clarify a range of matters that regard may be had to in respect of reasonable precautions. These provisions were prepared based on section 49H(4) of the Civil Liability Act 2002. This is a guidepost and a non-exhaustive list and does not alter the original intention of this provision.

Amendments were made to the terms of the review of the bill under clause 74. These include assessing the operation of the act in advancing the principles and balancing rights and freedoms with specific reference to freedom of religion, beliefs and expression, parental rights, the rights of the child and freedom from harm and discrimination. In addition, the effect of the act on healthcare, therapeutic and counselling outcomes for persons in relation to their gender identity or sexual orientation is also included in matters to be canvassed by the review.

These amendments were developed in discussion with the Premier. Again, it was a constructive process that allowed for balanced terms of reference that cover a full range of rights and freedoms. An amendment was also made to include agender in the definition of gender identity under the Anti-Discrimination Act 1998. An amendment was also made to explicitly outline the power of the tribunal to make an order that a person cease or refrain from engaging in a conversion practice. These two were introduced by Ms Johnston, the member for Clark, and the added clarity on these particular matters was valuable.

A series of amendments to remove any retrospectivity from the bill were also made. These were the removal of conversion practices as a reportable conduct and changing the application of limitation periods to be prospective only. I note, in respect of reportable conduct, the existing definition covers conduct that causes or is likely to cause significant emotional or psychological harm to a child. On this basis, we believe a conversion practice could reasonably be captured by this already, particularly in serious circumstances. The retrospectivity provisions are also worked through with minister Jaensch.

This is a bill where a wide range of matters have been subject to considerable discussion. It’s testament to the goodwill and sincerity of members that these matters were all able to be worked through largely to the satisfaction of all members who are in overall support of the bill, but more importantly, in many ways, largely to the satisfaction of advocates for this reform. A number of whom are joining us in the Council Chamber today, and I will get to them shortly.

I believe the good faith and collaborative nature of the amendments being worked through the House has put the bill in good stead for this place.

Clause 5 of the bill provides a definition of conversion practice as well as clearly setting out circumstances that are not a conversion practice. To meet the definition of a conversion practice, a practice or conduct needs to meet all the following requirements:

– it must be directed towards a person;

– it must be a practice or conduct motivated by that person’s sexual orientation or gender identity or perceived sexual orientation or gender identity;

– it must be for the purpose of changing, suppressing or eradicating a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity, or to induce the same.

There’s been a lot of commentary regarding this definition, but I remind members that definitions around the country where these reforms have been brought in are extremely similar. This definition, other than the inclusion of the word ‘eradicate’, is the same as the definition in Victoria that’s been in operation for five years, and very similar to the definition in New South Wales.

This bill has more criteria that must be met than in the ACT and Queensland, which do not require conduct to be motivated by the person’s sexual orientation or gender identity. It is similar to South Australia. However, South Australia is the only jurisdiction requiring the conduct to occur more than once. Survivors and advocates are clear that this is problematically restrictive. Opponents of the legislation have proffered the South Australian definition as their preferred approach, but it’s important to recognise that requiring conduct to occur more than once does not fundamentally alter the kind of conduct that is captured. We cannot think of any other examples of prohibited conduct that people get a free pass to do once to any number of people. This, in our view, would be extremely problematic.

I want to point to the government’s definition of conversion practice in their draft 2024 bill. That said –

Subject to this section, for the purposes of this Division, a conversion practice is a practice that attempts to change or eradicate the sexual orientation or gender identity of the recipient of that practice.

Our bill actually has an additional requirement to the government’s 2024 bill in that the conduct needs to be on the basis of a person’s actual or perceived sexual orientation or gender identity. The Attorney-General’s definition in 2024 didn’t include suppression but is otherwise similar to the construction of definitions across the country.

While any conduct that doesn’t meet the definition is not a conversion practice, clause 5 also explicitly clarifies a range of conduct that does not constitute a conversion practice. The provision of a health service is exempt if it’s conducted by a registered health practitioner, if they in good faith consider it appropriate for the person, and if it complies with all relevant legal, professional and ethical requirements. Conduct is also exempt if it is genuinely facilitating a person’s coping skills, development or identity exploration to meet the person’s needs.

The bill also makes it clear that a range of conduct is not of itself a conversion practice. This includes participating in a public debate, expressing belief, expression that a belief ought to be followed, providing religious teachings, relationships and sexuality education, general requirements in relation to religious orders and discussion, guidance, support or advice from guardians. A number of specific health practitioner conduct is also covered, including providing information about treatment and non-treatment options, identity exploration and detransitioning.

Some of the concerns raised by faith leaders and questions asked of us in briefings relate to clause 5.4, the avoidance of doubt provision in the bill. A lot has been made of the qualifier ‘of itself’, the words ‘of itself’. In the other place, Mr Jaensch provided a very well-articulated explanation of these provisions. His statement was –

What I am familiar with is, through the debate and some of the matters raised with me, raised in social media and elsewhere where there was this genuine concern from people who were saying, ‘Now I can’t even talk to my kids,’ or, ‘Now I can’t even teach my religion’. ‘I can’t even participate in a public debate now because it will be illegal’. [tbc]

That’s not true. If people are actually worried or actually led to believe that those things by themselves, in and of themselves, were conversion practices, then they’re not. In the context of this document, if those things were done and directed towards a person and on the basis of their sexual orientation for the purposes of changing or inducing, et cetera, then they can be. If they’re done in conjunction with other things that establish a pattern or a program or a cumulative effect of having that intention, then they’re not of themselves; they’re in with other things.

For the people who are saying, ‘I can’t believe that we won’t be able to even talk to our kids anymore about gender and their bodies and those sorts of things’: yes, you can. That doesn’t attract this attention. If you do that as part of a pattern activity with the intent of the matters identified in 5(1), then you’re in a grey area.

To add to Mr Jaensch’s well-described summary, the qualifier ‘of itself’ is there to prevent the misuse of the clause. This means that the listed conduct does not ‘itself’ constitute a conversion practice or evidence of a conversion practice but may be assessed alongside other factors to determine whether or not a conversion practice has occurred. This means that if someone expresses their view that there is a moral imperative for people or a person to be a particular sexual orientation or gender identity, (4)(b) provides that saying this is not inherently a conversion practice. If someone goes on to assert that all people should live their lives by these rules, (5)(4)(c) also provides that saying this is not inherently a conversion practice. If that is the extent of the conduct, there is no conversion practice.

If, for example, a person went on to tell an individual their same sex attraction is a disorder or that they’re broken or need healing and then instructed them in what they needed to do to cure this disorder, then a conversion practice has likely occurred. Alternatively, if these general statements were made in a pointed way during a session with an individual in which the individual’s sexual orientation was being discussed and the context made it clear that a person was trying to change, suppress, or eradicate that person’s sexual orientation on the basis of their actual or perceived sexual orientation, then that context may also indicate a conversion practice has occurred.

A common concern raised by opponents to conversion practices legislation is the so-called ‘chilling effect’ on legitimate conduct. Unfortunately, opponents also incorrectly claim that this legitimate conduct is captured. One of the purposes of avoidance of doubt provisions is to mitigate this misinformation and prevent the chilling of conduct that is not a conversion practice. The provision provides clarity and assurance to the community that this bill is carefully drafted to ensure there’s no impact on the right to freedom of religion and belief, on regular prayer, conversations between health professionals and their patients, and conversations between guardians and children that explore identity and sexual attraction.

‘Of itself’ is a term commonly used in avoidance of doubt provisions across a number of statutes; for example, section 72(4) of the Biosecurity Act 2019, section 16(6) of the Farm Debt Mediation Act 2024, section 76VC of the Gaming Control Act 1993, and section 57 of the Radiation Protection Act 2005. All of these provisions specifically use ‘of itself’ as a qualifier in avoidance of doubt provisions, and these are just a few relevant examples.

For more evidence of the way avoidance of doubt clauses are designed to explain and clarify matters without influencing the nature or substance of a bill as a whole, we can consider the Attorney-General’s own bill to ban conversion practices. That bill did not use the term ‘of itself,’ but it did use an equivalent qualifier in its avoidance of doubt clause. It read:

For the avoidance of doubt, a practice that amounts to no more than the expression of an opinion, idea or belief by a person, including a statement of religious principle or the provision of parental guidance, is not a conversion practice for the purposes of this Division.

It’s similarly qualified and, in fact, lists a much narrower range of conduct. I understand an amendment will be moved to remove the words ‘of itself,’ as well as ‘for the avoidance of doubt.’ I caution members not to support those amendments. This clause was never designed to create exemptions from the ban on conversion practices, and despite what some have claimed, we’ve never described it as such.

Creating exemptions for conversion practices based on the conduct listed in this clause would fundamentally undermine the purpose, the intent of this bill. Removing ‘of itself’ and ‘for the avoidance of doubt,’ would create significant risk of allowing conversion practices to continue. For example, if there was a blanket exemption for prayer, a person could continue conducting conversion practices under the guise of prayer. If all of these paragraphs became outright exemptions in the bill, it would not in all likelihood ban conversion practices. It’s important to recognise that if such an amendment or amendments were successful, it could turn a clause that’s designed to be explanatory and clarifying and – I would argue, comforting – into one that alters and undermines the clear intent of the bill itself. Such an amendment risks either allowing conversion practices to continue legally or, at the very least, of creating ambiguity over whether they can; ambiguity that will undoubtedly embolden those who wish to continue to change, suppress or eradicate the sexual orientation or gender identity of another person.

There have been many good-faith questions and concerns raised about this clause, but the reason the strongest opponents of this legislation have expended so much effort pursuing the removal of the term ‘of itself’ is they believe that, if successful, this move has real potential to undermine the principle and the purpose of the bill: to prevent conversion practice from occurring. To ensure the principle of this bill is fully and clearly upheld and to ensure the bill does have the intended effect, this clause shouldn’t be altered in any way that would either allow or encourage conversion practices and the harm they cause to lawfully continue in Tasmania. That would be an egregious wrong against the human rights of our fellow Tasmanians to be safe, included, respected and treated equally under the law.

There’s also been commentary regarding the term ‘suppression’, and its lack of definition. New South Wales, Victoria, South Australia and Queensland all include ‘suppression’ in their ban on conversion practices and none of them provide a definition, nor is there a definition of ‘change’ or ‘eradicate’. The vast majority of terms used in the legislation are not defined. Where a term is not defined, the common meaning is defaulted to. ‘Suppress’ is a commonly used term that is not ambiguous and its meaning is well understood.

In our conversations where we’ve discussed suppression, it’s emerged that people’s understanding of the term ‘suppress’ is not the issue; the issue is they’re interpreting the term in isolation and not in conjunction with the other elements of the bill. The context of suppression requires it to be on the basis of a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity, as well as for the purpose of suppressing their sexual orientation or gender identity.

One of the issues that arises is celibacy or abstinence. Both of these things are suppression of a person’s sexual activity, not their sexual orientation. Therefore, it couldn’t meet the definition of a conversion practice given the matter of being celibate is not about a person’s sexual orientation or for the purposes of suppressing the sexual orientation. If the question of celibacy or abstinence is based on a moral judgement about a person’s sexual orientation and for the purpose of stopping them from living in accordance with that sexual orientation, that may be captured as a conversion practice.

Similar concerns have been raised in connection with the proposed new definition of ‘sexual orientation’. Paragraph (a) of the proposed definition reads:

a person’s emotional, affectional, and sexual attraction to, or intimate or sexual relationship with persons of a different gender, the same gender, or more than one gender.

The concern is that the term ‘intimate or sexual relationship’ would open the door to abstinence or celibacy being captured. While this uses the language of intimate or sexual relationship, it doesn’t use this in isolation. If we strip away the extra words for the purpose of intimate or sexual relationship, it would read ‘a person’s intimate or sexual relationship with persons of a different gender, the same gender, or more than one gender’. Rather than discussing a person’s intimate or sexual relationships generally, it’s discussing them specifically in relation to their basis in gender. In short, it describes sexual orientation as commonly understood and doesn’t capture sexual activity generally. This is the definition increasingly being used around the country, and I note there’s the same interaction between definitions used in Victoria sexual orientation and conversion practices.

Nonetheless, we have considered this question thoroughly and we’ve consulted with some very key stakeholders, and do not believe there’d be adverse consequences that may arise from removing the phrase ‘intimate or sexual relationship’. On this basis, we’re inclined to support such an amendment to make it absolutely clear that the definition does not capture sexual activity generally.

Part 2 establishes a general prohibition on conversion practices as well as a positive duty for a person to take reasonable and proportionate measures to eliminate conversion practices engaged in themselves, or by a person acting on their behalf. The positive duty does not give grounds to make a report to the commissioner, but a serious breach of the positive duty may give grounds for an investigation. Clause 9 stipulates that no criminal or civil liability is created, except as expressly provided by the bill, and that compliance with this act, does not, itself, mean that requirements of other legislation have been met.

Now to offences under the act. Part 3 sets out the offences related to conversion practices. These are offences for engaging in conversion practices, taking a person outside of Tasmania for conversion practices, and advertising conversion practices. Division 1 sets out offences for conducting a conversion practice that causes injury. These offences are punishable under the Criminal Code. The bill establishes an offence for engaging in one or more conversion practices that cause injury. To prove this offence, a person must be shown to have intentionally engaged in a conversion practice, which caused injury, and they were negligent as to whether they would cause injury.

Division 2 sets out offences for taking a person outside of Tasmania for conversion practice on similar terms to the Division 1 offence. It is an aggravating factor for both these offences if the conversion practice is conducted on a child, or a vulnerable person.

Division 3 establishes an offence for advertising a conversion practice for which proceedings may be brought by the commissioner, a person authorised by the commissioner or a police officer. The bill provides that employers or principals, the person in charge, are responsible for a conversion practice of employees, contractors and volunteers, unless they could not have known of, or prevented the conversion practice. A proceeding against a Division 1 or 2 offence punishable under the Criminal Code, cannot occur without the written consent of the Director of Public Prosecutions.

The bill captures conduct that occurs outside of Tasmania, if a significant part of the conduct occurs in Tasmania, or the effects of the conduct occurred in full or in part in Tasmania. This is to make sure that after conversion practices are banned – and Mr President, I sure hope they are – our laws cannot be skirted by involving practitioners who are based outside of Tasmania.

Now to the Education Prevention and Response Scheme. Parts 4 through to 8 establish the office of the Conversion Practices Commissioner, as well as the elements of the Education Prevention and Response Scheme. The Anti-Discrimination Commissioner is, by virtue of that office, also the Conversion Practices Commissioner. The response scheme consists of a report process and an investigation process. Any person can make a report that a conversion practice has occurred or is occurring. The commissioner can respond to a report with targeted education, a facilitation process, by referring it to a more appropriate body, or not responding in certain circumstances. A party’s participation in the facilitation process is entirely voluntary and any party may withdraw at any point. It is also entirely confidential unless both parties agree otherwise.

The matters cannot be used in civil or criminal proceedings, except for administrative proceedings relating to obstruction or the giving of false, or misleading information, during the facilitation process. If an agreement in this process is reached and the commissioner is satisfied both parties have freely entered into an agreement, it becomes an enforceable order, as if it were made by the tribunal. Either the commissioner, the respondent or the person affected by an alleged conversion practice can apply to have the commissioner’s report assessed by the tribunal. This provides a de facto appeal avenue. As well as an avenue for compensation, for losses or damages.

The second element of the Education Prevention and Response Scheme is an investigation. This may be launched on the commissioner’s own initiative, if they consider that a matter is of a serious or systemic nature, that it relates to a class or a group of persons, that the act may have been contravened, and if it would advance the objects of the act. Unlike the report process, in an investigation the commissioner has the power to require documents and people’s attendance to answer questions. For either of these, the commissioner must provide a reasonable period or deadline to comply. A person is not excused from providing information on the grounds that it could incriminate them. However, as is the case in other acts, any information provided is exempt from evidence in civil or criminal proceedings, except for proceedings relating to the information being false or misleading. The commissioner may also order that a person’s identifying information is protected if necessary to prevent victimisation or to protect their employment, privacy or other lawful interests, or that any information obtained in the investigation is not published or is restricted.

In responding to an investigation, the commissioner may take no further action, enter into an agreement with a person, accept an enforceable undertaking, issue a compliance notice and publish a report on the investigation. The subject of an investigation may enter into an enforceable undertaking as a result of the investigation. Such an undertaking may stipulate particular actions the person will do, or refrain from doing, for the purposes of complying. Undertakings may be published in a public register, and any information may be omitted if necessary for safety or privacy purposes, to avoid prejudicing an investigation or an enforcement action, or to comply with the requirement of the act or any other act. If the enforceable undertaking is not complied with, the commissioner may take the matter to the tribunal. It may issue a compliance order, discharge or vary the undertaking, or make any other order the tribunal considers appropriate.

The commissioner also has the power to issue compliance notices, a person to whom a compliance notice is issued may appeal the notice as a whole or particular terms of the notice to the tribunal. The tribunal may confirm, vary or quash the notice and may direct the commissioner to take such action as the tribunal considers appropriate. If the compliance notice is not complied with, the commissioner may take the matter to the tribunal. The tribunal may issue a compliance order, vary the notice, order the commissioner to withdraw the notice, or make any other order it considers appropriate. In the case of employees, contractors and volunteers, the employer or principal person in charge, is taken to be responsible for conversion practices unless they can establish, on the balance of probabilities, that reasonable precautions were taken to prevent the practice from occurring.

Now to consequential amendments. Amendments are made to the Criminal Code Act 1924, the Limitation Act 1974 and the Civil Liability Act 2002 to include conversion practices as a form of child abuse. The amendments to the Civil Liability Act 2002 include conversion practices under the provisions that deal with organisational liability for child abuse. This sets out that organisations that have a responsibility for children have a duty of care to prevent people associated with the organisation from using that position or association to conduct a conversion practice and establishes liability for the organisation if that duty of care is not met. The Limitation Act 1974 amendments include a conversion practice as a form of child abuse that is not subject to a limitation period, as is generally the case for amendments to limitations periods, the changes to these periods apply to past conduct. However, any cause of action would be assessed under the rules as they were prior to the commencement of the bill. The Criminal Code Act 1924 amendments include conversion practices as an offence for the purposes of failing to report the abuse of a child offence. The bill also amends the definition of sexual orientation in the Anti-Discrimination Act 1998 to ensure asexual and aromantic are included in the definition. The bill provides for the act to be independently reviewed after five years of operation.

While the bill has been informed by the Tasmanian Law Reform Institute report, there are material changes and there are a number of reasons for this. The starting point of our drafting was the TLRI report and recommendation. Throughout the drafting process, a number of significant challenges with implementing this model became apparent. One example was the recommendation that the Civil Liability Act 2002 be amended to clarify that a conversion practice is a civil wrong. The advice received was that this was fundamentally incompatible with the act, specifically, section 3(A)(1), which reads, ‘This Act does not create or confer any cause of civil action for the recovery of damages.’

There are other amendments to other acts that, while not outright incompatible, had similar conflicts with the frameworks under those acts and the TLRI report. There were also practical concerns with the multi-regulator model that was proposed by the TLRI. We’re aware from the experience of the recent commission of inquiry, that a fragmented regulatory model creates gaps, confusion and circumstances where the appropriate entity to investigate becomes uncertain. There was also significant difficulty in determining what the appropriate entity would be to investigate certain scenarios under the model. The TLRI model effectively extended the role of the Health Complaints Commissioner to the primary regulator for non-healthcare settings which would not be within that officer’s expertise.

I note the Health Complaints Commissioner made a submission to this bill supporting the Anti-Discrimination Commissioner’s role in performing the functions that have been allocated to them. The Anti-Discrimination Commissioner recommended the establishment of the Conversion Practices Commissioner. It’s also relevant that the TLRI’s report was handed down shortly after legislation to prohibit conversion practices was introduced in other jurisdictions, and subsequent to that report there’s been a period of intervening time when the Victorian model in particular could be evaluated after five years of operation.

I also need to clarify and correct several matters raised by the TLRI in their submission to our draft bill. The TLRI’s submission to the draft bill claimed the extraterritorial application of reforms relating to conversion practices was not addressed in the TLRI’s report. Respectfully this claim is not correct. I know that page 180 of the TLRI report reads –

The new provisions of conducting an illegal conversion practice and conducting an illegal conversion practice on a child should be included under the reference provisions in section 192A(1) of the Criminal Code so as to provide those offences with extraterritorial effect.

The TLRI’s submission also states, ‘the proposed bill makes it an offence to take a person from Tasmania for the purposes of conversion practice’. This is the approach in Victoria, NSW, South Australia and the ACT. This gives the proposed bill a wider application than most conduct that is criminalised under Tasmanian law. There is only one existing offence under the Criminal Code where it is an offence to remove a person from the state for the purpose of conducting behaviour that is unlawful in Tasmania. This applies in relation to female genital mutilation, where it is an offence to remove a child from Tasmania with the intention of having female genital mutilation performed on that child and that is Section 178B of the Criminal Code.

What the TLRI’s submission to our draft does not acknowledge is that the TLRI report says on page 180 –

A provision should be added to section 178B of the Criminal Code to prescribe the removal of a child from Tasmania for the purposes of performing a conversion practice on that child. In either case, the relevant wording of section 178B of the Criminal Code Act should be replicated.

The submission from the TLRI states –

Under the proposed bill, amendments are proposed to the Criminal Code Act of 1924, Limitations Act of 1974 and the Civil Liability Act of 2002 to include conversion practices as a form of child abuse. This was not considered in the TLRI’s 2022 report.

Again, this is objectively incorrect. The summary of the report on page 5 states –

Complainants should have access to civil liability schemes. In addition, criminal offences should be enacted as a last resort for sexual orientation, gender identity conversion practices that cause serious harm. In both cases, conversion practices directed towards children should be categorised as a form of child abuse.

Recommendation 14 of the report reads –

Ms WEBB – Do you need to see more time?

Ms O’Connor – I think I’m going to be okay.

Mr PRESIDENT – You have 5.5 minutes left.

Ms O’Connor – Thank you Mr President and thank you honourable member for Nelson. Recommendation 14 of the report reads,’ the Civil Liability Act should be amended to include SOGI conversion practices as a form of child abuse for which organisations responsible for the care of a child are vicariously liable’.

Page 169 reads –

The definition of child abuse in section 5C of the Limitation Act should be amended to mirror the definitions in 49H of the Civil Liability Act, namely, to include conversion practices performed on a child.

Furthermore, page 180 of the TLRI report reads –

The new provision of conducting an illegal conversion practice on a child should be included as an abuse offence under section 105A(1) of the Criminal Code.

All of these provisions were included in the bill on the direct recommendation of the TLRI report.

This bill has been many years in the making. It brings Tasmania into line, should it pass, with the majority of other states that have already legislated to protect LGBTIQA+ people from the harms, often lifelong, of conversion practices. It’s based on legislation tried and tested elsewhere. It fulfils the state’s obligation to protect people, especially children and young people, from harm. At the same time, it protects free speech, faith teaching, pastoral care, conversations with children and between doctor and patient where a person’s intent is not to deny someone the ability to be themselves. These would not be conversion practices under this bill.

At the heart of this bill are all those people who suffered the despair, loneliness, shame and years of life lost from such conversion practices. We recognise their trauma and the enormous courage of those who’ve publicly shared their story. Their truth has been the catalyst for this bill, which is carefully designed to make sure never again should others suffered as they as they have.

I want to thank all at Equality Tasmania, pay great respect to Rodney Croome, Tasmania’s relentless advocate for LGBTIQA+ justice. The years-long campaign to end the torment of conversion practices has borne fruit in this bill.

I also want to thank Matt Garvin, Mission Director of the Tasmanian Baptists, for coming in to brief us this morning; the head of the Islamic Council of Tasmania and Muslim faith leader, Kazi Sabbir; Matt Sharples from the Australian Christian Churches Tasmania; Sharon Doherty from Hillsong; also the group of people who came in to speak to us afterwards, I’m very thankful; Rodney Croome from Equality Tasmania; Glen Worrall, who has lived experience, many decades, two decades or more, of being subject to conversion practice; Dr Miranda Hann, a GP who’s a specialist in gender affirming care; and Reverend Liena Hoffman, from the Uniting Church. I’m very thankful.

In closing, I want to echo the voice of one survivor: ‘we’re okay and lovable just as we are’. Mr President, I commend the bill to the Council.

Recent Content