TASMANIAN HOMES AND HOUSING BILL 2026 (No. 48)

Home » Campaign » Cost of Living and Housing » TASMANIAN HOMES AND HOUSING BILL 2026 (No. 48)

Mr BAYLEY (Clark) – Honourable Speaker, I rise to talk to the Tasmanian Homes and Housing Bill 2026, to welcome this bill, and indicate that the Greens are willing to support it. We know there are a number of different amendments, and I will foreshadow a couple of amendments of our own. It’s a bill that’s been four years coming, in many ways, and it is welcome that it has finally hit the table. I thank departmental staff for their briefings. We’ve had a couple of briefings on this, and that’s been really detailed. I also thank some of the stakeholders who put such comprehensive submissions in to both the selective consultation process and then also the engagement with me as I was working through this, and nutting through amendments and the like.

It is welcome that this is bringing Homes Tasmania, or the functions of Homes Tasmania, back into the government fold and back into the business of government. The Greens voted against the Homes Tasmania Bill in 2022. We were concerned about outsourcing it to a statutory authority, the debt, the issues associated with it being loaded up with debt, and adequate government oversight and government accountability. The government has come to the realisation that these functions rightly sit within government and within Building Tasmania, the old State Growth, and we agree that’s where it should sit. We need, as a state, to come to terms with the housing crisis and embrace the challenge of providing Tasmanians with adequate housing. Housing is a fundamental human right and it is the responsibility of government to provide housing. I will talk more about the human rights elements, particularly as they’re reflected in this bill, later on, but I will start with that proposition because that puts a significant and serious onus of responsibility on government to deliver.

It is utterly unsustainable and unacceptable in a country like Australia, in a state like lutruwita/Tasmania, that we have the housing crisis that we do and the statistics that we do when it comes to housing and homelessness. The housing crisis is really twofold and those aspects are interlinked. We had the former CEO of Homes Tasmania acknowledging in budget Estimates a couple of years ago that the failures of the private rental market are impacting on the waitlist and the wait times in the public housing sector, and that’s logical. As people are bumped out of the private market because they can’t find a home, they can’t afford a home, they can’t keep a home, they’re undoubtedly going to fall through the cracks and need to be caught by the public and social housing structures in this state. And then if they fall through those cracks, they need to be caught by the homelessness services provided by the state. That was the job of Homes Tasmania and that’s the job of the new agency within the department.

When it comes to the private rental and private housing markets, things happening at the national level in terms of capital gains tax, negative gearing and the like are having an impact on the market and are positive changes that, over time, will assist with the inequality when it comes to housing in this country, the fact that housing is essentially used as a financial commodity and wealth-making venture, as opposed to a fundamental human right. But there’s more we can do here as well. There is a review of the Residential Tenancy Act. That is very welcome. That has been brought forward slightly, and we are going to engage in that and encourage constituents to engage in that really strongly because we do need to give renters more rights and more protections. We need to have rental controls. We need to ensure that no‑cause evictions are a thing of the past. Tasmania has some of the worst housing stock in the country. We need to make sure there are minimum standards in our properties so that Tasmanians have the comfort and the healthy environment they deserve. And also that in a climate like ours, with energy prices the way they are, they can manage their energy bills. So, there’s much more we can be doing there.

Of course, supply is a massive issue. There are so many challenges when it comes to supply. We’ve just debated a modular housing bill and how we can get more prefab-type houses into the market and how we can support that to happen. But when it comes to supply, the quickest, simplest and easiest thing we can and should be doing is to be reining in short-stay accommodation. We are bleeding rental properties in this state, particularly in this city. From long-term rentals, they are bleeding into the short-stay tourist market. That is something this government is culpably ignoring its responsibility to deal with. We’ve had the Hobart City Council play every card in its hand, effectively, to try and rein in this practice and now is finally going to the Planning Commission to try to resolve it at the planning scheme level. But it is something that this government and this minister could easily fix. It could give all councils the power to be able to determine short-stay accommodation conversions in their municipalities, to rule out the conversion of long-term rentals in residential areas to short-stay accommodation, and the like. It is something this House needs to grapple with. The reform is needed, and we will be making strong representation to the Residential Tenancy Act review to deliver that reform.

Where the private sector fails, the public sector needs to step in, and again, we’ve seen a failure of the system. We’ve seen fudged statistics – vacant land and others counted as housing. We’ve seen ever-worsening statistics. The latest Homes Tasmania dashboard, September 2026, has 5653 applicants on it. If we look at September last year, it’s 5336. It has gone up, despite the lofty claims of the government over the last year. It has gone up by some 300-odd people. It’s simply not good enough because we know those 5507 applicants back in April represented 9504 individuals waiting for homes. So, it’s not 5000 Tasmanians waiting for a home; it’s nearly 10,000 Tasmanians waiting for a home, and alarmingly, almost one in three of those is a child. In April, there were nearly 750 children in the north waiting for a home, 782 in the north-west and 1381 in the south waiting for a home. That is not good enough. If we cannot find homes for our children, we have to look seriously at ourselves and at the decisions that we are making. It’s an utter failure.

Of course, those applicants are waiting ever longer. The average time to house a priority applicant at the moment on the rolling 12-month average is 91.4 weeks. It’s almost two years. That was in September. It’s simply not good enough. It’s a crisis on the ground. We know it and we hear it from the service providers. It’s a crisis in the statistics, and we can see it there in black and white.

It’s also a crisis in the reviews. To their credit, after pushing from members – and I credit the member for Franklin, Mr O’Byrne – the Crawford review identified significant governance flaws, poor housing delivery and diluted operational focus, hindering public housing delivery and homelessness services. It issued 20 recommendations.

In many ways, this bill is a manifestation of those recommendations and that review and it’s very welcome. There was also the KPMG review into Homes Tasmania’s finances which identified governance issues, risk management issues, planning reforms, efficiency, co‑investment and land supply issues. This bill is an opportunity to get it right. This bill is an opportunity to reset the framework and make sure that bringing the functions of Homes Tasmania back into government is done in a way that is seamless but actually successful and actually starts to deliver.

I pay a tribute to staff. None of these failures are a criticism or a failure of staff as individuals. We know that staff are under significant pressure when it comes to the jobs that they do. I ask the minister explicitly in terms of staffing, given the cuts to Building Tasmania, for some detail around the expected staffing changes, which hopefully increase when it comes to the housing function within Building Tasmania, because we know there’s 250 jobs in Building Tasmania that are set to be cut under austerity measures in the Budget. We can’t have that because they’re already under pressure. The Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute (AHURI) published a report earlier this year – or maybe it was late last year – which identified the trauma that frontline housing services workers are experiencing in dealing with their clients. Significant trauma being transferred to those housing workers. We need to make sure that these people have got the resources they need to do their job, that they are supported to do their job, that they are supported in terms of their health and wellbeing to deal with the challenges of their job. That is something that we want to follow through with really strongly to make sure that this government takes the health of its workers seriously when they’re doing these incredibly tough frontline jobs.

I want to talk about housing as a human right because it is enshrined in this bill and that’s welcome. The government is to be commended for including, in this bill, recognition that housing is a human right, which mirrors a light provision in the Homes Tasmania Act 2022. However, as the Tenants Union of Tasmania made clear in its submission to the bill, it’s not enough to recognise a human right. It also needs to be protected, enforced and respected in principle. It begs the question: what assurance can we have that the state government will protect and enforce and respect the right to housing?

This is a real question, because when the honourable Meg Webb MLC sought to amend the Holmes Tasmania Bill in 2022 to recognise housing as ‘a fundamental human right,’ the government agreed to the amendment on the basis that ‘While acknowledging a right does not create one, we are prepared to accept the proposed amendment.’ That’s simply not good enough. I want to take a moment to read into the Hansard, the exchange here because it’s really important. On 27 September Ms Webb moved the following amendment.

The first amendment, page 28 subclause (2) paragraph (b)

leave out ‘a basic human need’.

Insert instead ‘a fundamental human right’.

And she says:

We have made a change around the language to do with rights in other parts of the bill and we had agreement on that. I’m not going to speak to it in detail but I’ll answer any questions if there are any.

Ms Hiscutt, who at the time was leader of government business, said:

Madam Chair, the bill as it stands currently, recognises housing as a basic human need. This was deliberately worded to recognise the importance of housing in our community and as a principle to guide Homes Tasmania and its work.

We have taken advice on the amendments proposed by the member for Nelson and are satisfied that it retains the intent of the current bill. While acknowledging a right does not create one, we are prepared to accept the proposed amendment.

Then the amendment was agreed to. It’s crucial in this bill that the government commit to more than just acknowledging that housing is a fundamental human right. There are countless examples of public and community housing providers in Tasmania failing to uphold the right to housing.

There are a couple of cases. In the case of Parsons v Director of Housing (2018), Tasmania’s public housing body, Homes Tasmania, sought to evict an intellectually disabled man on the basis that his lease was ending, despite his having lived in the property for 10 years. Homes Tasmania did not seek to afford the tenant with any procedural fairness. They simply told him that he was being evicted because it was the end of his lease. At the hearing, his Tenants’ Union lawyer told the court that if he was evicted, he would be homeless as he was in sole receipt of a disability support pension. The Magistrates Court agreed with Homes Tasmania that it was irrelevant whether a tenant was at risk of homelessness and that all tenants, including public housing tenants, could be evicted on the sole basis of the lease ending. Shame.

It was only after the Tenants’ Union of Tasmania appealed the decision and a Full Court of the Supreme Court ruling that Homes Tasmania finally recognised that they did indeed need to afford their client procedural fairness. Since that decision, all Homes Tasmania tenants have been provided with genuine reasons for their eviction and have had an opportunity to challenge their eviction in court – an important human rights safeguard that was only won after being fought all the way to the highest court in Tasmania.

Another example is the case of Jordan v Community Housing Limited (2024), in which Lorraine Jordan moved into her son’s Community Housing property in Launceston in 2017. When Lorraine moved in, the Community Housing landlord agreed that she could live there and listed her on the residential tenancy agreement as an approved occupant, not as a tenant. In September 2023, Lorraine’s son moved out of the property. The social housing provider served a trespass notice on Lorraine on the basis that she was not a tenant and therefore a notice to vacate did not need to be served on her. After Lorraine and her cat were locked out of her home, the Tenants’ Union of Tasmania filed an application with the Magistrates Court arguing that she was a tenant and therefore entitled to a key to the property. Lorraine lost her case in the Magistrate’s Court on the basis that she was not a tenant. On appeal, the Supreme Court found that although Lorraine was listed on the lease agreement as an ‘approved occupant’, she was in fact a tenant because her income was taken into account in assessing the rent payable for the property. In other words, because Lorraine was living in the property, the household income was higher and more rent for the property had to be paid. The effect of the Supreme Court decision is that persons listed as ‘approved occupants’ in social housing will be recognised as ‘tenants’ and provided with all of the protections set out in the act.

The effect of the Supreme Court decision is that persons listed as ‘approved occupants’ in social housing will be recognised as ‘tenants’ and provided with all the protections set out in the act if they are providing value – that is, the household rent is higher because the ‘approved occupant’, or ‘occupants’, are living in the property. After the decision was handed down, Homes Tasmania reported that 39 per cent of all social housing properties have ‘approved occupants’. As a result of Lorraine’s courage in standing up for her right to remain in her home, around 4300 adult ‘approved occupants’ in social housing are now protected against arbitrary eviction.

A final example of the lack of human rights protection from public and community housing providers is the range of policies adopted for persons in prison. Whilst Homes Tasmania will charge its tenant $5 per week for up to eight weeks, a community housing provider in northern Tasmania charges approximately $350 per fortnight at the same time as the person imprisoned receives no financial assistance at all. One tenant is charged $40 while serving a short imprisonment or until bail is obtained, while another tenant is charged $2800, meaning that they are likely to be evicted for rental arrears when they are released.

All of these examples demonstrate why social housing providers must all commit to a review of their policies and procedures to ensure that they meet the high standards expected of legislation acknowledging that housing is a fundamental human right, seeking a commitment from government to review its own approach, and work with providers regarding implementation of the recognition that housing is a human right. So, minister, we are seeking strong commitment from you, and I would urge that the minister for Housing reiterates that in the other place, that enshrining the fundamental right to housing in this act is actually going to mean something; that there will be amendments to policies and procedures to give effect to it; and that it will not be just the new agency that has those policies and procedures, but that the government works with housing providers across the sector to make sure that housing, as a fundamental human right as recognised in this act, actually means something and it actually means something for the tenants we’re trying to protect.

I have an amendment myself I want to flag that speaks to cultural sensitivities, in particular in relation to Aboriginal tenants and tenants from multicultural communities; from culturally and linguistically diverse communities. It’s one that’s really important in an inclusive Tasmania, in a Tasmania that is seriously trying to embrace multiculturalism, trying to engender inclusion and make sure we facilitate acceptance. And I pay tribute to our Migrant Resource Centre and some of the work of former premier Peter Gutwein in relation to trying to make sure that acceptance is widespread and all‑encompassing. It’s really important that this bill recognises that some tenants have particular needs when it comes to their cultural identification, their cultural sensitivities, and that they are accommodated. It’s an important principle, and we have an amendment that would enshrine that.

When it comes to Aboriginal people, for a long time I’ve been doing work with Darlene Mansell and others in the north of the state, and I hear repeatedly from them where, as much as possible, there needs to be self‑determination in the housing space. There needs to be sensitivity to cultural aspects of their lives, be it their family links, be it sorry business. I’ve spent a lot of time on Cape Barren Island, and I know there’s quite often challenges there, and I think if we can enshrine the need for cultural sensitivity and acknowledgement in this act, it will be very welcome.

There was also solid representation in the submissions from both the Tenants’ Union and Shelter Tas for the need, or concern, about the concentration of powers in the Secretary, without appeal rights. The decision of the Secretary on the eligibility of a person is final, and it’s really important that this does get resolved. I’ll just read from the Tenants’ Union’s submission:

The bill defines an eligible person as including persons who require housing due to their health or mobility needs or to ensure their safety or due to the person living with them, or intending to live with them, being in need of housing assistance. Pursuant to Clause 5.3 of the bill, eligibility for social housing will be determined by the Secretary of Building Tasmania. However, there is no express right of review.

That, from our perspective, is unacceptable. I mean, it is a fundamental right, in my mind, in our mind, that tenants should have the right of review. It’s a fundamental right in relation to housing as a human right. We actually have an amendment drawn up that’s exactly the same as the Labor Party’s. I know the member for Franklin is going to move that, and we’ll support that wholeheartedly, because that is something that needs to be woven into this bill.

One of the things that Shelter Tas was deeply concerned about were the level of commitments for the Stage 2 reform in this bill. I accept that this is a high‑level framework that brings the functions of Homes Tasmania back into the purview of government and there’s way more work to be done. But Shelter was really clear in what they wanted, and they actually wanted to see some of Stage 2 sort of framed up in this legislation. I accept that maybe that’s a difficult thing to do in legislation, but I want to urge the minister, and particularly the minister upstairs, to give really strong commitments around what you are preparing to do and how you’re preparing to go about it when it comes to the Stage 2 reforms.

Just quickly, I want to go to the second reading speech. I know that you’ve spoken about these Stage 2 reforms, and you say:

This subsequent reform process will help to identify potential legislative and non‑legislative reforms and present several potential pathways for tangible action and outputs, for example: additional reform … the potential to pursue additional legislative reforms … short, medium and longer‑term strategic actions … future policy development … identify further ways in which, together, we can refine and enhance how the Tasmanian housing system works.

There’s a fair bit of trust to be taken by housing providers and social housing, social and public housing tenants and advocates. There’s a fair bit of trust in those words, and Shelter Tasmania explicitly wanted to see clear timeframes, a clear scope, the consultation process, the publication of findings, a tabled government response, and explicit commitment to agreed housing and homelessness outcomes. They want to see that built into this legislation, and so I’m asking you, minister, and your minister upstairs when he gets to his feet, to be really clear in his second reading, and your summing-up, about exactly how you’re going to deliver those things in Stage 2:

  • How are you going to deliver clear scope?
  • What are going to be the timeframes?
  • What’s the consultation process?
  • How are you going to publish the findings?
  • What are you going to table in response to the views of stakeholders and an explicit commitment to agreed housing and homelessness outcomes?

That’s what we need to see.  It’s the clarity and the certainty that stakeholders need given they’re putting a fair bit of faith in government at this point.

The asset retention and reinvestment safeguards: I know Labor has an amendment in relation to the fund, but stakeholders have been asking for transparent criteria, ministerial justifications when it comes to asset retention and reinvestment, and appropriate oversight. We need to make sure that what little money – Well, we need to make sure that more money is going into housing, but we need to make sure that every single dollar of it is spent properly and is reinvested into the right places, so it absolutely needs to be clarified. We’ll have a close look at the Labor amendment when it’s put and debated.

I want to ask a question about the discrepancy with how the parliamentary process is used to swap the status of Crown land and housing Crown lands. Section 11 talks about how Crown land becomes housing Crown land. There’s no parliamentary process. The minister administering the Crown Lands Act makes the decision. So, when Crown land becomes housing Crown land, the minister makes it unilaterally. But the converse in Section 12, when housing Crown land is to become Crown land, it’s a disallowable instrument as built into this legislation. It begs the question for you, minister: why the difference? Why is there a difference in how the conversion of each of those Crown land categories are treated? I guess we have some concerns in relation to this. It should be an even process. The disallowable process seems to be the appropriate way and mechanism to deal with it. So, we look forward to your response, and I’ll work with my colleague in the other place, Ms O’Connor, to make sure that this issue is really clearly on the agenda up there. If we can’t find a satisfactory response here, we’ll ask questions between now and when the bill goes upstairs and make sure that’s resolved.

With that, in the little time I’ve got left, I want to reiterate that we support this bill, that we welcome this bill, that this bill is needed. But this bill alone will not fix the housing crisis. Fixing the structural issues in the government provision of housing and homelessness services won’t, in itself, fix the housing crisis. We need to see additional investment. We need to build more public and social housing. We need to make sure that the private market is as renter-friendly as – that the private market supports the fundamental right of housing as a human right as well. We urge the government, after doing this, to put their shoulder to the wheel to make sure they’re investing adequate money to build the houses Tasmanians need and that the housing and homelessness sector is funded adequately, to acknowledge that people are falling through the gaps and that until you fix those gaps, you need to adequately funded the community services sector.

I commend my colleague, Ms Rosol, for her speech last night because she really pulled apart the Treasurer’s media release of yesterday in relation to the budget process; how shallow and heartless the government’s approach to this next budget cycle is. It is really telling the community services sector not to bother making budget submissions, that they need to make it up on their own. That’s simply not good enough. Homes Tasmania’s failures over the last four years and the ever-growing public housing applicant list and the wait times demonstrate how serious this crisis is, and it has a knock-on effect. People fall through the private market into the public and social housing sector. They fall through that and we need to be catching them at every single opportunity. To do that we need the right structures, the right funding and we need to support the people that are doing the job. That’s both the people within Building Tasmania that are going to be serving that function and also people in the community services sector who are holding people up.

We support the bill. We look forward to the committee stage and talking about the amendments, and we look forward to the functions of housing going back into government where they belong.

Recent Content