Mr BAYLEY (Clark) – Honourable Deputy Speaker, I want to take some time on the adjournment to recap where we’re at in the stadium debate, that slow-moving train wreck that promises to compromise our city, damage its values, consume the attention of government for years and condemn generations to paying off its debt – the reasons the expert recommended it not proceed.
Next week we’ll get another declaration on the cost blowout of this project, the fourth: $715 million; $775 million; $945 million; $1.13 billion, and now whatever the Premier is provided with over the weekend. There’s no certainty that this blowout will be the last. In fact, you can bet that it won’t be. This is a government that has hidden the true cost of the stadium all the way along and denied the realities of price pressures affecting construction projects the world over, from a freestanding house to a major infrastructure project, let alone a stadium on a complex, constrained, contaminated and contested site. It was clear almost immediately that the conflict in the Middle East was going to drive up construction costs more than they already had, as fuel costs rose and supply chains were affected. On behalf of Tasmanians, we brought these concerns to the Liberals at the beginning of May, six months ago. In the interests of transparency, we asked them to develop a new cost estimate for the stadium. The Treasurer at the time admitted the stadium cost could go up, but the Liberals voted against our motion.
While the motion was carried by a majority in the lower House, when it came time to deliver in August, the Liberals refused the will of the parliament, citing concerns over the tender process. Under pressure, the Premier did concede to releasing the updated cost before the contract was signed. But knowing the Liberals’ lack of transparency and aversion to scrutiny, it wouldn’t have been surprising if they were planning to release the costs on the morning before the contract was signed in the afternoon, perhaps on Christmas Eve. When asked, the Premier refused to stick by his promised cost cap of $875 million. In parliament on October 27 and 28, we first asked the Liberals to admit another stadium cost promise was to be broken and bring the new cost back to parliament. On the same week the upper House passed a motion calling for the same thing. While the Premier lauds majority parliamentary support for the passing of the order, it was secured on the promise of a clear cost cap, a written cost cap tabled, spoken, recorded in Hansard. So, ahead of parliament returning this week, we joined with multiple MPs from both Houses and wrote to the Premier seeking an extension of parliament so the new stadium cost could be brought back for scrutiny. On Tuesday, my colleague, Dr Woodruff, asked the Premier five times whether he stuck to his cost cap promise. Five times he dodged the questions, but that spoke for itself. This Premier was breaking his second cost cap promise. On Wednesday, Dr Woodruff again asked the Premier if he stuck to his cost cap. Under increasing pressure from across the parliament, this time he acknowledged he’d be surprised if the stadium met his budget and made the commitment to come clean with the price. This is a massive shift from the government, and it wouldn’t have happened without pressure from the Greens, Ms Johnston, others on the crossbench and Labor.
Let’s be clear, this is the bare minimum transparency that Tasmanians expect. Even if the stadium costs are released on Tuesday next week, it still won’t allow for the scrutiny the public deserves or a new opportunity for parliament to decide. The Premier made a big deal of promising Tasmanians and the parliament that they were capping spending on the stadium at $875 million. A number of MPs believed him, and it secured their vote for the stadium. In response to revelations this week, two are calling for a new parliamentary scrutiny. A third is no longer sitting, replaced with a member who signed onto the letter calling for an extension. Whether you support the stadium or not, we all agree it’s consequential for Tasmania.
With chaos in the public service, as the pain of $1.4 billion of cuts begin to bite, a stadium recommended refusal at a cost of $945 million is utterly untenable at over $1 billion. In the face of past commitments and the cost figure now blowing out further, not giving the parliament a new chance to decide represents a hubris and indifference to intergenerational debt that will be a great stain on this Premier, this government and this project ‑ if it ever gets built.


