In Committee
New Clause B to follow Clause 21
Ms O’CONNOR – Thank you. I probably should have waited to hear what the government’s latest position is on this amendment. This is a big and consequential amendment, and I know that it seeks to address an identified issue for primary producers. I understand that, but because it’s such a consequential amendment, in terms of the bill that we’re debating, and we have some concerns, up front I do want to acknowledge the clear effort, through the iteration of this amendment, which is now at version 7, and that’s a good thing. It means it’s been through rigorous testing by the mover, to the greatest extent possible. There’s a clear effort here to make sure it’s targeted. I understand that.
But we’re not comfortable – I’m speaking now on behalf of the Greens – we’re just concerned about supporting this amendment without a more thorough process of consultation on it.
I understand that what we’re dealing with here, is in part of byproduct of the fact that the amendment bill changes the categorisation of firearms. But I do point honourable members to the advice that we’ve been provided by Tasmania Police. Perhaps it’s advice that should give us a cause for pause, and maybe we can explore this some other way. Tasmania Police have provided advice, and they ask us, please to not support the amendment. The new clause (X) which creates the new section 33(a) in the principal act, as described by Tasmania Police, ‘Allows for the creation of associated primary production licence’, which would be a type of category C licence. That ‘such a licence could be applied for if there was a relevant primary production application.’ The relevant primary production application would be for a person who provides services, other than as an employee. If a person engaged in primary production, and we heard from the mover what those circumstances might be, and on a family property, or a network of family properties. The amendment creates a limit of three or five relevant primary production applications per property, depending on the property size. I ask the honourable member, even though we had some explanation then for the rationale for the 800-hectare threshold in the amendment, it seems to me that was the best guesstimate number of how, and where, you draw a line.
We had a lot of talk earlier in the discussion about caps, about, where does this number come from? I ask the question here: where does that number really come from? The proposed amendment allows the person who has an associated primary production licence to possess, and use, one straight-pull action rifle, for the purposes of suppression of vertebrate pests, on that relevant land only. The clause clarifies that it doesn’t include other category C firearms.
There’s two amendments we’re dealing with here today, there’s a new clause (x), and a proposed new clause (y), which follows clause 23. We will get to that shortly, but they’re connected. On the new clause (y), which would amend section 40 of the principal act, which are requirements relating to primary production. The amendment seeks to expand section 40, to include a relative of a person, if the relative lives on, or near, the land, and provides services, other than as an employee, of a person in the Principal Act. Here is the advice that we have been given by Tasmania Police, as we consider this amendment. [TBC 3.24]
It is the view of Tasmania Police that this will expand the availability of category C licences to recreational hunters.
Then it flows that,
There will be more category C firearms, but only the straight pulls in the community.
Its view is:
This will create further administrative work for firearm services, firearm safety services, further checking of evidence requirements, to confirm property sizes et cetera, and it creates a new type of licence, but does not say how long the licence will be granted for.
Police are also of the view that:
The expansion to family members, under clause(y) is too wide. A family member need only be near to the land and does not require any activity or evidence linking the person to the productivity of the farm, or the carrying out of the farming business. Simply just to be a relative, and to live on, or near, the land.
There’s no definition of what is ‘Near’, numerically. Is five kilometres near? Is 100 kilometres near? What is near? The view of the police is that:
While there may be some argument for unpaid family members, who do not draw a wage, in this case the drafting is too wide, and will allow for applications for category C licences from persons who have no other association than being a relative and living near to the farm. This will expand the number of category C firearms in the community, without clearly thinking the same to be required for carrying out the primary production business on that farm.
As I said, I recognise that this amendment comes from a good place. It’s identified that there is potentially a real issue for primary producers. I will just pause here for a moment and if anyone wants to know how the war on wildlife is going, have a look at the property protection permits that are issued. We even let people here kill platypus, but I digress. I couldn’t help that.
But on the basis that this is such a consequential amendment, it clearly seeks to remedy a potential issue for primary producers. I wonder if there’s another way we can look at this amendment, or if we can bundle it into an examination of caps because a number of members have said, well, this needs more consideration and perhaps we should have an inquiry, but on this issue, in fact, in the same way that we support Tas Police’s position on caps, we are prepared to listen to this advice and act with caution on this amendment and on that basis, at this point in time we can’t support it.
Ms RATTRAY – Deputy Chair, the government supports the amendments moved by the honourable member for Murchison. By way of explanation, these amendments address the concerns the government identified with the earlier version and, in the government’s view, strike an appropriate balance between maintaining safeguards around category C firearms and recognising the practical needs of primary producers.
As honourable members are aware, the government’s concern with the earlier amendment was that it would have provided unpaid pest controllers with access to the full range of category C firearms and that would have presented a significant expansion of access for a class of persons who had not previously been eligible for category C licences under Tasmania’s Firearms Licencing Network. But the amendment before the Council today, version seven, is substantially narrower and for unpaid persons who assist with pest control activities, access is limited to a single straight‑pull action firearm. It does not provide access to all category C firearms. Importantly, it also preserves access to a firearm that many of these individuals could lawfully access prior to its reclassification under this bill without creating a broader pathway to category C firearms more generally.
These amendments acknowledge the reality of farming life in Tasmania, and the honourable member for Murchison certainly outlined that in her contribution when she spoke to the proposed amendment. The amendment recognises the reality of extending eligibility to certain relatives of a primary producer. However, it is important to be clear about the limits of that provision. This is not an open-ended expansion to all family members. The amendment applies only to relatives who live on or near the relevant property or who are regularly engaged in the primary production business, and it’s also important to distinguish between those family members and the separate category of unpaid pest controllers.
So, eligible family members are recognised as part of the farming operation itself. I think a lot of us with rural backgrounds could give you many examples of that particular arrangement. They’re not being treated as unpaid pest controllers. Consistent with the arrangements that apply to primary producers and others engaged in the farming business, they may hold licences for up to three category C firearms where the requirements of the act are met. By contrast, the pathway created for unpaid pest controllers is considerably more restricted. Their licence is confined to the use of one straight‑pull firearm for vertebrate pest suppression on the relevant primary production property. Written permission is required and limits apply to the number of licences that can be associated with a property, and importantly, the firearm can only be used for that vertebrate pest suppression on the relevant primary production property. This is not a broader authorisation to use category C firearms beyond that property or for other purposes. Those distinctions are important. The amendment does not create broad new access to category C firearms; rather it recognises that farming in Tasmania, as has been identified, is often a family endeavour and ensures that those family members who live on or near the property and are actively involved in the enterprise and continue to assist with its operation, including pest management activities. At the same time, it confines the new unpaid pest controller category to a very limited authority involving a single straight‑pull firearm.
In conclusion, the government’s view is that the approach appropriately reflects the realities of primary production in Tasmania, while maintaining the safeguards that parliament expects in relation to firearm access. For those reasons, the government’s previous concerns have been addressed by the narrowing of version 7, and the government supports the amendment and acknowledges the work of the honourable member for Murchison.
Ms O’CONNOR – There are two pieces of advice that have come from Tasmania Police to government about amendments or proposed amendments to the amendment bill that we are debating today. On both occasions, the government has ignored Tasmania Police’s advice. I think every member of this place should be concerned that the government, apparently so freely, ignores advice from Tasmania Police.
Now that we understand that this amendment is government policy, perhaps the Leader for the Government could respond to some of the matters raised in the advice from Tasmania Police. Now that we’re creating a new type of licence, how long does the government foresee these licences being granted for, given that there doesn’t seem to be any clarity in the amendment? Does the government have an understanding of what ‘near’ means? What does ‘near’ mean in the context of this proposed amendment? Does the government disagree with Tasmania Police that the drafting is too wide?
This is a piece of advice that asks us to be cautious here. We’re talking about firearms, for heaven’s sake. If I could just take people to the objects of the bill, they make it really clear that the purpose of the bill is to prioritise public health and public safety. It’s right there on the first page of the bill. In order to do that and be sure that we’re doing that, we should be listening to our law enforcement advisers, the people who are actually responsible for the process of licensing and registration, the checking of storage of firearms. Yet, on critical matters, where there are legitimate questions about public safety and access to particular categories of firearms, on those critical questions, where two pieces of advice have come to government saying we support caps, we don’t support this amendment, which extends the potential use of category C – shotguns – it’s been ignored.
Now, the only thing here that even mildly reassures me is that this amendment has come from the honourable member for Murchison, and I know how much work’s gone into it. But I’m very, and we should all be, disappointed and worried that this government feels so casual about the status of Tasmania Police advice, including the Police Commissioner, noting that police are the first responders, noting that Tasmania Police are put at particular risk when there are firearms in the community that are part of an incident, if you want to call it that, so Tasmania Police unarguably have a particular safety concern for their workforce as well. We have some tragic history that points to that risk, tragic recent history.
I understand that this is now government policy. I’m not certain and we can’t be certain that it’s in line with the objects of the amendment bill. We can’t be certain. We have had concerns raised with us by our law enforcement advisers, so the three questions the government is now obliged to provide full answers to Council on are –
- How long is this proposed new licence to be granted for?
- What does ‘near’ mean, because in Tasmania, if you live in Evendale, you live near Launceston, so what does near mean in the context of this amendment, and
- How does the government respond to the concern raised by Tasmania Police that the drafting is too wide and that it will allow for applications for category C licences from persons who have no other association than being a relative and living near a farm.
It makes the point, this advice, that this amendment will expand the number of categories C firearms in the community. Madam Chair, I hope the Leader can give some really clear and frank answers to those questions.
Ms RATTRAY – Thank you very much and I will do my best with a bit of technology. First, it’s not a government policy. It’s the government working with the member for Murchison to support the farmers and they have contacted and there’s been those versions right through, from 1 through to 7 to make sure that it fits with some comfort around that. The government is satisfied that if this amendment is read in conjunction with the existing section 40, that it is supposed to be ‘near’ and ‘in the business of farming’.
We also have some advice from OPC. The link to the activity on the land is actually within paragraph b) of section 40, which requires the applicant to:
- b) produce evidence to the commissioner’s satisfaction that he or she intends to use the firearm solely in connection with the suppression of vertebrate pest animals on the land and the destruction of animals to avoid pain and suffering.
An applicant must meet both paragraph A and B of section 40 and the reference to land in paragraph B is a reference to the land used for primary production as referred to in paragraph A.
As for the use of ‘near’, that was deliberately drafted to be vague so the commissioner could determine if the applicant lived near the land. It would not make sense in the context to have a hard distance that meant an applicant must live within, because that would mean, for example, and this is the example that the honourable member for Murchison also used, that if an applicant who lived 1 kilometre primary production land may be eligible for the licence, but an applicant who lived 1.1 kilometres from the land would not be eligible.
Ms O’Connor – What if they’re 10 kilometres away is that near?
Ms RATTRAY – Obviously, the commissioner will use in this case her discretion or the person who’s delegated. So, I trust that answers the questions that were posed.
Ms O’Connor – Sorry I just need an answer thanks Madam Chair if I could.
Madam DEPUTY CHAIR – The honourable member for Hobart third call.
Ms O’CONNOR – Thank you. There wasn’t any clarity provided in that answer about the matter raised by Tasmania Police in the advice that says this creates a new type of licence but does not say how long the licence will be granted for, perhaps the Leader could just address that part of the question.
Ms RATTRAY – I will attempt to have a response to that. Thank you.
Madam Deputy Chair I don’t have a firm answer on what the licence time frame might be but under the Firearms Regulations of 2026, 17 – Period of Licence, there are various categories and they have various years or timeframes connected to them. For instance, for the purpose of section 45 H of the act, a Category A B or H Firearms Licence may specify that the licence is in force for the period of:
- Three years from the date of issue or
- Five years from the date of issue.
Then it goes on Category C Licences is to be granted to a person who is a primary producer may specify that the licence is in force for the period of:
- 3 years from the date of issue or
- 5 years from the date of issue.
So, there are limits. There’s another category as well, Category C. Category C firearms are granted for a person who is employed or engaged in the business of primary production and is in force for the period of 12 months from the date of its issue, so there are already various timeframes in place.
Ms O’Connor – Will this be set by regulation?
Ms RATTRAY – The government would anticipate, for this particular category, that you would use, for the purpose of section 49(b) of the act, a category C firearms licence would be for a period of 12 months from the date of its issue. So, they’re already quite well articulated in those regulations.


