Mr BAYLEY – This is some of the most alarming news I have heard all day. To think that you would raid CSL – money that is going to a whole range of important community support opportunities – to fund an infrastructure commitment – to implement this kind of card‑based –
Mr STREET – It is only one option that would be considered.
Mr BAYLEY – Why would you consider it when this card is not going to automatically end problem gambling across the board? It only tackles one part of the gambling sphere. We know that online gambling and a whole range of other gambling activities are incredibly problematic. Why on Earth would you raid the Budget for community organisations that are helping support people through a whole raft of gambling challenges to put this single piece of infrastructure in?
Mr STREET – The bids to the community support fund are made annually as well. I would not see that we would be not funding any particular organisation that makes a bid to that fund in order to spend money on this. However, there have been cases of money being left over in the fund. I do not think you can be wholly supportive of the PCG as a harm‑minimisation measure and not acknowledge that it is going to reduce problem gambling and that, maybe, there is a case to be made for some money to come out of the community support fund for targeted assistance towards the installation of this program.
Mr BAYLEY – That assumes the community support fund is adequately funded all the time.
Mr STREET – It’s gone from $4.18 million to $8.36 million.
Mr BAYLEY – Sure, and problem gambling is also a significant issue that’s escalating as well. That’s not to say that $4.1 million is enough or that 8 odd million dollars is enough either.
On it, would you need to change the regulations for the government to raid that fund to invest in implementation of the card?
Mr STREET – Under the Gaming Control Support Fund Regulations, discretionary distribution to the Fund in addition to money otherwise payable out of the Fund. Under these regulations, money may be paid out of the Fund in accordance with Regulations 6 for any of the following purposes:
Gambling harm prevention and harm‑minimisation programs or initiatives.
Direct support program services or initiatives aimed at the minimisation, prevention of gambling harm, or both.
Research activities relating to the minimisation of prevention of gambling harm.
Community capacity building and community development projects, programs or initiatives aimed at the minimisation of prevention of gambling harm or community sport and recreation activities.
Mr BAYLEY – Most people would read them in the context of community support organisations and their eligibility for those funds, as opposed to government itself. You’ve got control of the Treasury books. You can find this money and invest it in parallel with maintaining the CSL.
Mr STREET – The community organisations don’t bid, the departments do. Then the community organisations bid to the departments.
Mr BAYLEY – This is a piece of infrastructure as opposed to education or other initiatives.
Mr ROOT – I would say, minister, currently funding comes out of CSL for the Gaming Exclusion Scheme, which is a piece of harm‑minimisation infrastructure, so it’s not a new concept. I can’t speak to where the government will land, but, as the minister said, within the regulations there is approved allocation for investment in infrastructure that acts as a protective factor against gambling harm, which is what the minister was getting to.
Mr SWAIN – Treasury’s advice would be that it has to be needs‑based, targeted, and usually of a fixed duration. Typically, if it was focused on anything, it would be a capital component. It would not generally go to ongoing operations that you would look to the industry to fund. Having been involved in a few major reforms, and this is a significant reform, it’s very important to reach the new end state, but there’s usually some practical considerations to get there.
Mr BAYLEY – Minister, I’m going to ask again about the CSL and paying for this implementation. I hear you say that it’s just one option that’s currently under consideration, and I also hear that the CSL has in the past funded other structural initiatives, but I think most reasonably minded Tasmanians would expect that the Community Support Levy would go into supporting people and supporting the organisations that support people, and that this piece of infrastructure is the responsibility of government to implement. It is a government commitment. It’s a standalone piece of infrastructure that is yours to implement and pay for.
We’re seeing a situation where efficiency dividends are being imposed across departments and across the public service. It’s almost impossible to think that you wouldn’t take up the opportunity to raid that fund in order to at least absorb some of the cost of implementing this.
Why aren’t you prepared to rule it out to give some confidence to organisations in the bidding process for the CSL, and to make sure that Tasmanians can have confidence that you’ll put dedicated and real money into that piece of infrastructure? It is a standalone initiative that needs to happen and has now been a long commitment for government.
Mr STREET – Again, Mr Bayley, I only mentioned that it was a potential option.
Mr BAYLEY – I realise that.
Mr STREET – There was $1.235 million of unspent money in the CSL last year that rolls into this year. I believe in the PCG as a harm‑minimisation program. There will be contributions from the government and contributions from the industry towards the implementation of this. Like I said, the Community Support Fund is there as well as an option, but that’s all. I will not sign off on money coming out of the CSL that puts in jeopardy the harm‑minimisation programs that are funded from the CSL.
Mr BAYLEY – The question is: when will the taxpayer stop paying for the implications of the 2018 election? When will we stop? We’re giving money directly to the AHA; we’re paying taxpayer money to support vulnerable Tasmanians through this scheme. When are we going to stop paying for the harm that’s caused by these machines?
Mr STREET – I understand that that’s your position, Mr Bayley. I would have thought that the government’s position on implementing the PCG is a pretty fair indication that we disagree with the THA on this particular policy as well.
Mr BAYLEY – Is that why you pay them taxpayer money direct into their coffers?
Mr STREET – It’s not. There is money paid to the THA for a number of worthwhile programs that they run including Clubs Tasmania in my Sport and Recreation space, but other programs as well, training programs et cetera as well.
Mr BAYLEY – We just see and taxpayers see money continually flowing out to ultimately support people who are suffering at the hands of an industry that should not and could be dealt with by virtue of getting them out of pubs and clubs. Simply because of the outcome of the 2018 election and the commitments that were made there and the funding that was given to the Liberal Party, we’re in this situation.
CHAIR – Is there a question? If not, I’ll go to Mr Willie.
Mr STREET – Again. I understand your position but the THA is a representative organisation of a number of businesses who are significant employers and contributors to the economy in Tasmania as well. I understand that our positions on certain matters with the THA differ, but I think that the investments that the government makes into the THA’s programs are worthwhile contributions to the community as well.
Mr BAYLEY – The question is when our taxpayers going to stop paying money to support this industry that is so destructive?
Mr STREET – The government made election commitments to support the THA and we will fulfil those commitments, Mr Bayley.


