Ms O’CONNOR (Hobart) – Thank you, Mr President. Well, I thought, given what we’re seeing, particularly in the Northern Hemisphere at the moment, that it was a good opportunity to have a debate on the independent review of the Climate Change (State Action) Act 2008. Submissions to that review were accepted by the independent reviewers through September last year and closed in September last year. We’ve been presented with an independent review report, the 2024-25 Independent Review of the Climate Change (State Action) Act Report, and what have we had from government on it? Nothing.
Nothing out of the government on what is, and because it’s not going to be a particularly long contribution, I’ll go into some detail on the recommendations. This is a rigorous independent review of the Climate Change (State Action) Act 2008. It took representations from climate community organisations, community members, and it absorbed what feedback it was getting into that review process about community and public perceptions of the government’s response to what is unarguably a climate emergency.
In summary, what the review found about public feedback to this government’s response to the climate crisis is:
There remains an absence of defined responsibilities and measurable objectives that link planned actions to demonstrable progress in reducing emissions or building resilience.
And that is a long way of saying there has been no demonstrable progress either on emissions reduction or adaptation planning.
It goes on to say:
Stakeholder confidence in the Tasmanian Government’s ability to deliver meaningful climate outcomes remains low.
No surprises there. It points out that while we have been net zero since 2014:
it is driven largely by carbon sequestration from the land-use, land-use change and forestry (LULUCF) sector, rather than broadbased decarbonisation across the economy.
I’d like to focus today in my relatively brief contribution on the complete lack of adaptation planning on the part of this government.
There is a monster El Niño that has formed in the eastern Pacific that is unlike anything scientists have ever seen before or anything that is in the geological records. There was a large El Niño, a ‘super El Niño’ they called it, in the late 1870s, early 1880s, and because of the intensity and strength of that El Niño in the late 1800s, it’s estimated that globally around 20 million people died.
The El Niño that is boiling away in the eastern Pacific is gargantuan. We have never seen the likes of anything like it.
Sea surface temperatures. I have an app on my phone – when I want to torture myself about the state of the world – that will tell you land and sea surface temperatures anywhere you put your finger on the globe. A couple of nights ago, when I was having a look at that spot over the El Niño, the sea surface temperature in the ocean right there was 27‑28°C. Just to the west of the Spanish island of Majorca, they have measured in the Mediterranean a sea surface temperature of 33°C.
Europe, the United Kingdom, France, Spain, primarily, but it’s moving across Europe, is just now in its fifth extreme heat wave. We are seeing overnight temperatures in European cities in the high 20s.
It’s estimated that two-thirds of England is in drought.
We have seen pictures – we’re not living it right here and now – but we have seen pictures of monster fires in England; in Scotland, on those beautiful Cairngorms mountains on the outskirts of Edinburgh – fires the likes of which humanity has never seen. Fires in France right up to the city of Bordeaux. Fires sweeping through Spain; the island of Sicily; Canada, those beautiful temperate boreal forests of Canada are aflame in thousands of fires, and meanwhile, there’s a heat dome sitting over the United States. I don’t say this to be alarmist. It’s just the facts. I don’t say this to depress people, but we’ve got to wake up, and we have a responsibility to wake this government up, because what the scientists are telling us is that while this year will be the hottest in recorded human history, what the scientists are telling us very, very clearly, is that next year will be even hotter. Summer is coming to Tasmania and we have a government that is totally asleep at the wheel, and we should all be worried about that for our communities. It’s extremely serious. There are cities burning that never saw a bushfire before in the northern hemisphere. A million people have been evacuated in the city of Shanghai in China, not because of fires, but because of an intense, previously unnatural, large atmospheric river. Typhoons, the intensity of which we’ve never seen before, are happening more intensely and more frequently.
The reason I wanted to just remind honourable members tonight that this government, which wants to spend more than a billion dollars building a bloody stadium at Macquarie Point, has not even responded to the review of the Climate Change (State Action) Act, let alone do anything about the climate. The focus tonight for me is adaptation, because I am extremely worried about the city I represent, the people who live in it, but I’m extremely worried, as we all should be, about all our communities this summer and next summer. All of us need to be pressing the government to take it seriously. It is no exaggeration to say we are in danger. We are in danger and we’ve got a government that is pretending business as usual is acceptable.
Have a look at the last state Budget: cuts to the climate office, starvation funding, effectively, in the environment or the climate in which we’re living, for the TFES, for Parks firefighters, not enough going into the SES. I’m hearing extremely worrying stories about fire management in Kunanyi in the Wellington Park. Buck-passing: no, it’s not our responsibility, says Parks, it’s the Trust’s responsibility; and the Trust says, ‘Oh no, it’s Parks’. I don’t think we should care whose responsibility it is particularly, but the need for proper investment in resilience, in community fire safety, in firefighting resources, in engaging with communities, in talking to people about having a fire safety plan, they have to be our priority and they have to be our priority now.
We do not want to be standing here this time next year, after a hellfire season on this island, wishing we’d done more to press government. We’ve had a long debate today about holding government to account, about scrutinising government, about making sure that we meet community expectations. Well, on all of those criteria we’ve got a job to do. The recommendations for the Climate Change (State Action) Act review, all of which are being, to date, dismissed or ignored by government, are quite straightforward, and I encourage honourable members to go and read the independent review, because at least then it won’t be wasted.
First recommendation: the Tasmanian Government should establish an independent body to oversee implementation of the Climate Change (State Action) Act 2008 and strengthen trust, transparency and accountability in Tasmania’s climate governance. Well, obviously, and we had one of them until 2014. We had one of them under the Climate Change (State Action) Act. It was called the Tasmanian Climate Action Council, and the first piece of legislation that the then-environment minister, Matthew Groom, brought into the House of Assembly after they won government in 2014 was to abolish the independent scientific experts to advise government on climate mitigation and adaptation.
Ms Webb – We tried to put it in in this place when it came through, but of course it got blocked.
Ms O’CONNOR – Did you? Of course it got blocked.
Ms Webb – Yes.
Ms O’CONNOR – Oh, thank you for trying.
Recommendation 2: amend the Climate Change (State Action) Act to replace the four‑year review cycle with a new statutory review period set to at least every 10 years, and there’s a logic that’s put in there for that which is not unreasonable. Recommendation 3, and this is a huge area of government failure: establish a separate adaptation planning process in the Climate Change (State Action) Act 2008 that enables adaptation actions to be developed and delivered separately to mitigation measures. The climate change action independent review notes the lack of adaptation planning in this state and strongly recommends a separate adaptation planning process to address the gaps, to prioritise adaptation actions, strengthen accountability and improve engagement with local government and the community, because, of course, it’s those community conversations that are going to be so important in the months and years ahead.
Recommendation 4: amend the Climate Change (State Action) Act 2008 to increase transparency and accountability for sectoral emissions performance, and for honourable members who have not seen the latest greenhouse gas emissions accounts, I commend them to members; but what you will see in the graphs that go back to 1990 is that the only area of the Tasmanian economy which is bringing emissions down is the land use, land use change and forestry area, and emissions across all other sectors of our economy have not come down. They’re static and there’s no accountability for that. We’ve got a government that crows about being net zero, continues to log native forests and pretends that net zero has got anything to do with anything that they’ve done, when even the independent review makes clear it was as a result of avoided deforestation through the Tasmanian Forest Agreement, where we were able to get the loggers out of 576,000 hectares of forest.
Recommendation 5: amend the Climate Change (State Action) Act 2008 to require climate change considerations to be included in major government decisions, particularly those with significant investment value and/or emissions impact; and on this, why are we building a $1 billion‑plus stadium pretty much at sea level? I think it’s a good question. I don’t think it’s a question the government ever asked itself, just like they’ve probably never paid much attention to the melting of the Antarctic ice sheet, where the Thwaites Glacier is cracking off as we speak.
Recommendation 6: review and strengthen engagement practices associated with climate change action to ensure deep, inclusive and continuous participation across all stakeholder groups, and it talks about the importance of strengthened engagement practices to embed engagement and inclusion in implementation of the act and its actions, rather than doing what governments sporadically does, which is, particularly in the context of this review, for example, every four years consult on a review of the act, so they become one‑off consultation processes rather than a sustained and ongoing conversation with the community about the reality, because it’s negligent to sugarcoat the truth here. People need to understand what’s coming and people need to be empowered to plan and to make choices; people need to know who to call in case of an emergency. People need to know who their neighbours are. Is there an older person up the street living on their own, if there is a bush fire barrelling over the top of Kunanyi? What do we know about our neighbours, for example? Who will look after the vulnerable people in a real fire emergency in our city? Because this government is not sparking those conversations, there’s this huge absence of knowledge and connection, which is frightening.
Now I tell you where you will not find a climate denier, that is in the RACT in Tasmania. They understand. Again, I recommend to honourable members, go and have a chat to the CEO of the RACT and his advisers and talk to them about fire risk. Talk to them about fire risk. I mean, I had the conversation about fire risk in Greater Hobart. Go and have a chat with RACT about fire risk in in your community.
So, at least we can engage with our communities in how you keep yourself safe. And that’s one of the reasons why – and everyone here is welcome to join – on the 30 September this year, my colleague Vica Bayley and I will be hosting an event at City Hall, an all-day event, which is an acclimatised event and it’s an opportunity for locals to come and talk to someone from the TFES, Red Cross, council representatives, have some information about how you need to plan.
So, I do welcome honourable members to the 30 September City Hall event, because it’s that old saying, isn’t it? Knowledge is power. And knowledge in this situation it might save your life, your family’s life, you’re elderly disabled neighbour’s life. Get the information, and I’d encourage other members to have those sorts of conversations in their communities too, because the sense I get is that people are crying out for information.
When we have information, there’s something calming about that. If we have a plan, if we know who to call, if we know that the emergency services will be there when we call them or need them, that is calming.
Recommendation No. 7, final recommendation:
Develop and implement a comprehensive communications and engagement strategy to improve transparency and visibility of progress under the act.
Now we’ve had a couple of opportunities now since the last election and since this review was brought down to talk to ministers about how they’ll respond to this review. It was a very disappointing engagement with the former and now disgraced minister for climate change, Ms Ogilvie, at the Estimates table in September last year, where I was trying to engage with her on the review of the act and what the government’s response would be, given that there’d been such a strong community push for strengthening of the act, and the very strong impression I was given was that there was no appetite in government to bring forward any amendments to strengthen the act in line with the recommendations of the independent review.
Then we get very unfortunate engagement with minister Abetz in last year’s Estimates. We were talking about the climate review and, you know, I’m talking about ineffectual adaptation planning.
Minister, do you recognise the importance of having really contemporary climate change legislation that drives lowering emissions, because no emissions have come down in nearly 30 years, but also that drives adaptation planning because at the moment it’s ad hoc and uncoordinated and it’s not going to keep Tasmanian safe?
And Mr Abetz said:
What I can do, Chair, is table the breakdown of the $250 million to which I referred previously, which I understand was a point in time in 2023, I tabled that which shows activities across a whole range of government areas totaling $250 million.
I said:
How about addressing your mind to the question about having contemporary effective climate change legislation, which the review has suggested we don’t have and that needs improving.
And he said:
I’ll leave that for further consideration by the government.
I said:
You don’t think it should be a priority of government to have a really contemporary piece of climate change legislation that lowers our emissions and drives proper adaptation planning?
Mr Abetz:
My answer remains.
And when I asked him about it in the Treasury portfolio in last year’s Estimates, I was talking about climate change, he goes, ‘That matter to which you refer,’ and I said:
Can you just say the words ‘climate change?’
As I said, that matter to which you refer.
We have a problem here. We have a government that doesn’t take it seriously enough and in closing, I will remind honourable members of the motion that this House passed last year, September of last year, this Council agreed that it notes the growing evidence of runaway climate change, and the impact extreme weather events such as fire, flood and drought are already having on Tasmanian communities, the environment and our economy. We acknowledged the Tasmanian Risk Assessment for Climate Change 2024, which warns of future increases in the severity of acute extreme rain and flood conditions, acute bushfire and wind conditions, more frequent and/or intense periods of extreme heat, and declines in rainfall across the state.
We noted the Tasmanian Government’s Greenhouse Emissions Report 2025, which confirmed carbon emissions across all sectors are not falling and that it is business as usual, despite scientists warning us of a climate in crisis. We recognise the report in a graph on page 8 of the Greenhouse Accounts, confirming the state’s claim to net zero status was the result of avoided native forest logging and burning from 2012 through the Tasmanian Forest Agreement. We expressed our disappointment that the Tasmanian government is in breach of its obligations under the Climate Change (State Action) Act to reduce greenhouse emissions. We noted the current review of the Climate Change State Action Act. We agreed, this is what we did by vote, unanimously, no opposition to this.
This Council agreed: the act needs a substantial overhaul to deliver emissions reductions and prepare Tasmanians to adapt to the intensifying impacts of climate change. We collectively called on the Tasmanian government to work with scientists, the community, farmers, business and industry leaders and the parliament to ensure the act is strengthened to reflect the urgency of the times, and we all agreed that this demonstration of leadership will give more young Tasmanians hope for a safe climate future.
So, I’m absolutely certain that when the Leader for Government rises to respond to this motion, we’ll have the same blah, blah, blah $250 million blah, blah that we’ve been getting since at least since the review started, but there’s been complete, negligent lack of action on climate ever since the Liberals were elected 12 years ago. We’ll hear more of it in the Leader for Government’s response. We’ll hear that the government takes this issue incredibly seriously, despite all the evidence pointing the other way, and I could almost write it, how that response will be, and I don’t put this on the Leader for Government because I know these speeches are prepared for her, and in a way I don’t care. I don’t care who’s written it; we should all care that a lot of the stuff that occupies our mind pales into insignificance relative to what is coming, and we are at this unique point in each of our lives where we have an opportunity to do something brave for the people who put us in here.
We cannot ignore this. We cannot pretend it’s going to be okay. It is not going to be okay. What we need right now is for the Premier, the Treasurer, the climate minister to snap out of their torpor and their denial. I mean, some of these people who are in Cabinet now have been among the worst climate deniers in politics in this country, and what we’re seeing, and we’re seeing it in Europe where thousands of people have died heat-related deaths, what we know is that climate denial is deadly. So, those climate deniers, they don’t deny the reality anymore. What they’re trying to make us do is live with it, and we can’t, we won’t live with it because the fact is, the scientists will tell us this: you know when we think about 1.5 degrees? It’s gone, 1.5 degrees is over, and so we start thinking about, oh, what does the three‑degree world look like? It looks like extinction, Mr President, for most species on this Earth but we need to understand that what global heating actually means until we stop emitting and find some way to remove this enormous body of carbon from the atmosphere, what it actually means is it’s just going to get hotter and hotter and hotter and hotter, so how did we keep our people safe in that scenario? Well, let’s do the bite sized chunk and just think about the next year.
All of us should be asking the government what they’re doing to keep our communities safe because the answer right now is close to nothing, and it really is close to nothing, and that is something that is deeply worrying, so my questions to the government are:
- When are you going to get serious about the science of climate?
- When will you fix this act up so it does the job that the parliament in 2008 intended it do?
- Do you accept the science?, and
- What are you doing to keep Tasmanians safe this coming summer and the next?


